Source: José Esteves, Poets&Quants
Summary:
Porto Business School Dean José Esteves argues that schools have moved fast on AI’s formal layer, including policies, assessments, and faculty training, while missing the informal layer where much learning happens: study groups, hallway conversations, and peer questions. An MIT report notes declining office-hour attendance, online discussion, and in-person study groups. Critical thinking and trust are built socially, he writes, and AI is making learning private. He urges leaders to design AI as a collective practice, measure what AI displaces, and protect productive friction and accountability. Porto will design AI into social learning this year and publish the results.
Observations:
- Most AI work in business schools has focused on policies, assessments, and faculty training, while the informal side of learning goes unmanaged and unmeasured.
- When students turn first to an AI model instead of classmates, faculty, or office hours, they lose the social settings where critical thinking and professional trust develop.
- Graduate programs that rely on online, asynchronous, or self-paced formats are especially exposed, because the social part of learning was already thin before AI arrived.
- As AI makes content and tutoring cheap, deliberately designed peer learning may become a program’s key differentiator, though it is costly and could become an equity gap.
Actions:
- Design group-based AI assignments, such as three students working with one model, where the team must decide what it believes and defend its reasoning.
- Track what AI may be displacing, including office-hour use, study group participation, peer interaction, and cohort engagement, alongside AI adoption measures.
- Keep some work AI-free and require students to present and defend their reasoning in front of peers, so they stand behind what they submit.
- Build intentional social learning into online and hybrid programs, such as structured study groups, live case discussions, and cohort activities, and feature it in recruiting as part of your value.
Topic Sentence:
As AI makes learning more private, business schools need to design the social side of learning deliberately, because critical thinking and trust are built with other people, not with a chatbot.
Related in the Digest: B-School Deans See An AI Future, But Are They Ready For It? — AACSB’s Deans Survey finds AI is a top priority and the biggest readiness gap.
Citation:
Esteves, José. “Porto Business School Dean: B-Schools Are Solving The Wrong AI Problem.” Poets&Quants, October 20, 2026. https://poetsandquants.com/2026/10/20/porto-business-school-dean-b-schools-are-solving-the-wrong-ai-problem/.
0 Comments